Neutral Buoyancy & Simulated Weightlessness
Grade Level: 6-8
Activity created by: Ranganath Weiner
Principal Investigator: Dr. Alan Hargens
In this activity, students are introduced to NASA research that uses water immersion experiments to study the effects of weightlessness on the vascular system. The goal of the activity is to build a model of a closed vascular system that has neutral buoyancy. This model consists of a drinking straw filled with air and yellow water and suspended in a tub of clear water. By experimenting with different amounts of water in the straw, students will calculate the ratio of air to fluid needed to attain neutral buoyancy. NASA scientists study giraffes, bats and other animals to learn about how blood circulation in mammals is adapted to gravity. NASA biologists also use water immersion experiments to simulate weightlessness and to investigate ways to counteract the effects of microgravity on the vascular systems of astronauts.
Two class periods, each lasting approximately 45 minutes.
For the entire class:
NOTE: You can use the pictures on the following pages to make overheads or slides
For each team of students:
For each student:
Optional Materials for Extension Activity:
NOTE: This activity will demonstrate to students that one ml of water weighs one gram.
1. Read Background for Teachers section near the end of this write-up.
2. Gather materials. Several weeks before the activity ask students to bring in clean, empty milk containers.
3. Prepare water and yellow food coloring the day before to allow water to come to room temperature. Store yellow water in the film containers and clear water in plastic one gallon milk containers. You should have one gallon of clear water and two film containers of yellow water for each team of students.
4. Sort materials into tubs, one tub for each team of students.
5. Make a photocopy of a Neutral Buoyancy Data Sheet for each student.
1. Why NASA studies animals. Explain to students about the use of animals, such as giraffes, in NASA studies. Giraffes are valuable models when studying the cardiovascular system because they are very tall animals that must overcome large gravitational effects when pumping blood from the heart up to the head. Giraffes, humans and other tall animals have high blood pressure at the heart level in order to maintain blood flow to the brain. When humans are in the microgravity environment of space, blood and other fluids move from the heart and lower body into the head because their vascular systems no longer have to overcome the force of gravity to pump blood to the brain. A similar thing may happen when giraffes lie down with the their head at the same level as their heart. Blood moves from the tissues in the giraffe's lower body up into the head. So much fluid can pool in the brain that the blood can no longer flow properly. This tendency to shift fluids may be one of the reasons that giraffes never let their heads rest at the same levels as their hearts, even when they're lying down. This fluid shift also occurs when humans lie in bed for long periods of time, or during space flight.
2. Buoyancy. Introduce the concepts of water displacement and buoyancy, drawing on the students' experiences with swimming and taking a bath. (When you get into a bathtub the water level goes up because your body is displacing water. Your body is buoyed up with a force equal to the weight of the water you displace, a phenomenon known as Archimedes Principle.) Ask students why some objects float in water while others sink. Immersion experiments, where subjects are neutrally buoyant in water, can be used to simulate the fluid shifts that occur when astronauts are in a microgravity environment. Inform students that they will simulate weightlessness in the classroom by making a simple neutrally-buoyant model of a closed cardiovascular system.
3. Gravity and the cardiovascular system. NASA conducts experiments on humans and other animals, including giraffes and bats, to study the effects of gravity on the cardiovascular system. Investigating the physiology and cardiovascular systems of animals that are uniquely adapted to gravity may help scientists find ways to counteract some of the negative effects of microgravity (such as fluid shifts) on humans. (More information about NASA facilities and microgravity studies can be found in the Teacher Background.)
Neutral Buoyancy & Simulated Weightlessness Activity
Instruct your students in the following steps of the experiment procedure:
1. Fill the tub with water. Remove materials from the tub and pour the clear water in the plastic tub. Measure the distance from the bottom of the tub to the top of the water (in millimeters) and record the information in a science journal (data sheet).
2. Airtight chamber. Put paper clips perpendicular to the body of the straw 5 mm from each end to create an air tight chamber. Then put the empty sealed straw into the tub of water. The straw should float. Record initial observations in the science journal.
3. Add yellow water. Pull the straw from the tub and remove one paper clip. Open one of the film containers and pour a small amount of the yellow water into the graduated cylinder. (Alternatively, use medicine droppers.) Record the amount of water in the science journal. Have one team member hold the straw with the open end pointing up, while a second member pours the yellow water into the straw without spilling. Place the second paper clip back on the straw and put the straw back into the plastic tub. Measure the height of the straw from the BOTTOM of the tub and record the information on the data sheet.
4. Try different amounts of yellow water. Repeat step 3 with different measured amounts of yellow water until the straw stays suspended at the midpoint from the bottom of the tub to the top of the water in the tub. The straw is neutrally buoyant when it neither floats nor sinks in the water. Record each experiment attempt on the data sheet.
5. Calculate volumes and ratios. After neutral buoyancy is achieved, calculate the volume inside the straw, using cubic millimeters as the unit of measure. Measure the length and radius of the straw. To calculate the volume, use the formula:
Volume = r2 L
Where r = the radius of the straw and L = length of the straw.
To calculate the ratio of water to air, first subtract the volume of water from the total volume of the straw. This will give you the volume of air inside the straw. Compare the volume of air to the volume of water to get a ratio of air to water in the neutrally-buoyant straw.
1. Have each team share their results. Then, as a class, calculate the average ratio of water to air. Explain to the students that by averaging all team results, a more precise result can be calculated.
2. Have a class discussion about the requirements for neutral buoyancy. Ask students how neutral buoyancy compares to microgravity conditions.
3. Have students write their findings in a science journal.
More Activity Ideas
Background for Teachers
Prerequisites: Students should be able to measure liquids in a graduated cylinder accurately or use a medicine dropper. Students should be familiar with the metric system. Students should be able to do simple calculations with a calculator or on paper.
Skills: Team work, calculating volume, measuring
Concepts: lab procedures, predicting, experimenting, recording
Additional Background information:
NASA has done a great deal of research with unusual animals. Giraffes have been studied because they are the tallest living animal on the planet and their blood circulation is most affected by gravity. (Dinosaurs were taller and may have been more finely adapted to gravity than giraffes.) Humans and giraffes both stand upright. The effect of gravity causes upright animals to constrict the arteries in the lower body and expand the arteries above the heart. This allows blood to flow up to the head rather than pool in the lower body. In giraffes, the difference in arterial wall size from the upper to the lower body is greater than in any other animal because of their tremendous height. In the microgravity environment of space, this relative difference in artery size isn't necessary because gravity is no longer pulling blood into the lower body. Instead, the blood and other fluids shift upward in the body of animals in space and the cardiovascular system reacts by attempting to balance the relative sizes of blood vessels in the lower and upper body. If people lived and worked in space for very long periods of time, would their blood vessels equalize throughout their bodies? Would long term exposure to microgravity cause damaging elevation of intracranial pressure because of fluid build-up in the brain? Scientists don't know the answers to these questions.
Another unusual animal studied by NASA Life Sciences Division is the bat. Bats spend much of their lives hanging upside down. This reverses the system that most animals have, with the result that bats have thinner blood vessels in the upper body and thicker blood vessels in the lower body. Biologists are interested in knowing how the cardiovascular system of bats overcomes the gravity effect of fluid build-up in the head, seemingly without having problems of elevated intracranial pressure. These and many other questions need to be answered and much work remains to be done.
One way to study the effects of microgravity is to be submerged in a large tank of water. NASA calls one such tank a WETF (Weightless Environment Training Facility). Inside this tank people can experience neutral buoyancy and simulated weightlessness. The similarities of this watery environment to that of the space environment make the WETF a good place to do space travel experiments and training.
Another way NASA studies the effects of fluid shift in microgravity is by having subjects do long term (30 days and more) bed rest studies. The subjects lie in a bed with their heads tilted down at a 6 degree angle. This causes a fluid shift to the upper body, with a build-up of intracranial pressure. Changes that occur while at a 6-degree tilt help NASA life scientists understand what happens to astronauts during long-term space travel.
Another way to simulate a microgravity environment on Earth is to fly in NASA's KC-135. This airplane flies up to 35,000 feet then drops to 24,000 feet in a series of parabolic arcs. Each time the plane drops from 35,000 feet to 24,000 feet, the passengers in the plane experience microgravity, but only for about 20 to 30 seconds.
Key words: neutral buoyancy, microgravity, Cartesian diver, cardiovascular