
Contents:
NASA's Pathfinder spacecraft and its Sojourner rover have done an amazing job of characterizing the rocks surrounding their Ares Vallis landing site. But Pathfinder (renamed the Sagan Memorial Station in honor of astronomer Carl Sagan, 1934-1996) was also a weather station, recording temperature, wind speed and direction, and pressure. These familiar and easy-to-understand measurements, along with reports on clouds, dust devils, frosts and giant volcanoes, add to our understanding of Mars. The fact that we could receive daily weathercasts is a major reason Mars seems so real: like Earth, like our home states, it's a place with everyday phenomena.
The "Planet Explorer Toolkit" project was refined into two exciting activities that related directly to the National Science Standards and complemented existing Earth, space or general science curriculum in the classroom. But the main goal was that the activities were engaging, informative and FUN for the students!
Online at the Live From Mars site under Featured Events, you can find a brief
description of how Pathfinder collected weather data on Mars. That
description also provides links to more extensive information on
NASA/JPL's own Pathfinder project pages and the University of
Washington's LIVE FROM EARTH AND MARS project. (Not affiliated with WEATHER
WORLDS, but a great source of current Mars weather data!)
The challenge for students was to figure out what key weather measurements
they thought were most important to gather here on Earth, and then how to
obtain them, by designing, building and/or acquiring instruments to
collect these data.
As part of this process, students also had to figure out protocols
or procedures about how and when to gather data. For example, is it enough
to gather temperatures just at noon? Do you also need night-time lows? If
you want maximum and minimum temperatures, how should you go about
securing these? As another example: Pathfinder's temperature sensors were
set at three different heights above the Martian surface because
researchers knew there were great differences caused by just a few
centimeters (yes, centimeters!) change in elevation. Would such
measurements be relevant on Earth?
But students were not limited just to instruments paralleling those
actually on Pathfinder. There's no rain gauge on the spacecraft, but
rainfall is an important part of Earth's weather. Students were
encouraged to start from scratch and come up with their best ideas.
Temperature, wind, pressure, humidity, hours of daylight, cloud cover--
these were all areas that students considered.
There was a cost limit to keep everyone's ambitions in check: all the
instruments together must not cost more than $100. Students were not
expected to buy the instruments, but instead, borrow or make them.
In addition, there was no size limitation: kids could suggest and build
large anemometers and wind vanes. The challenge was more to figure out
how to monitor weather on Earth, rather than deal with size constraints
appropriate for launching an instrument pack to another planet.
After initial debate in class, students were invited to go online with
their suggestions, comments and brainstorms. Veteran PTK teachers
consider the online debate a key aspect of these collaborations. To
focus the task, teachers submitted only one plan per class. The process
of formulating that plan -- by in-class debate, posting online and
responding to other postings and by more internal discussion -- was made
into a rewarding activity for the students no matter whether the teacher
posted the final results to the list, or also left that to students.
Each class that submitted a plan received focused feedback from three
other classes in more or less the same grade level, as well as more
general comment from the entire list.
There were elementary (3-5), middle (6-8) and high school (9+)
categories. This provided transcontinental feedback to focus attention
and lend significance to their activities. Based on the feedback and
monitoring, the wider debate students came up with a final plan.
Based on review of all these plans, and with input from students and
NASA experts, students arrived at a final consensus set of instruments
and procedures. These
final class plans are now
in a permanent online gallery of student work.
Just as NASA's scientists had to come to agreement on a single set of
instruments that could actually travel to Mars and operate on its
surface, we tried foster one final consensus about WEATHER WORLDS, which
became the basis for Phase 2: Data Gathering.
WEATHER WORLDS enlisted NASA experts to respond to student plans and created
a final consensus plan which followed during Phase 2. Despite the expert
input, WEATHER WORLDS definitely was shaped by students' collective ideas
and suggestions.
All classes that submitted final entries received a Certificate of
Participation from NASA.
In this second phase of the activity, classes built their own WEATHER
WORLDS, using either the consensus plan developed during Phase 1, or
whatever other data sets they could access (local weathercasts or news
reports), but they were responsible for doing so on a daily basis and
assuring the data's accuracy. Their internal verification plans were
part of the information they provided when signing up.
Classes filed their daily reports in a standardized format. The
specific types of data that a class chose to collect was discussed
online during Phase 1, and classes were able to access this archive to
aide in making their decision.
For example, a younger class might have chosen to do temperature
readings at three heights every day. An older class could have chosen
to collect a comprehensive set of temperature, wind speed, air
pressure and cloud-cover measurements.
The raw data were mounted on the WEATHER WORLDS site in a way that made it
easy to capture or download for Phase 2. It was also displayed in a graphic
format, just like the student-generated cloud patterns seen on the Live From
the Hubble Space Telescope site.
While the data were being collected, WEATHER WORLDS hosted an online
discussion of possible ways to analyze the accumulating data. Once
more, NASA experts made some suggestions, referring to Pathfinder and
Earth-orbiting weather satellites, but students themselves had the
final say.
During the Live From Mars broadcast, "Today on Mars," some of the
classes that had collected data and already begun work on their
analysis were be featured.
Final WEATHER WORLDS reports were posted on the web site. Classes that
submitted daily data received online recognition. All classes that
submitted a full analysis of their weather data received a
certificate of participation from NASA.
The idea behind WEATHER WORLDS was to give students the feel of real world
science. Not only did they gather data in ways parallel to what Pathfinder
did on Mars, they also used the Internet to debate plans with their peers,
something that NASA scientists also have to do.
Designing for Data: Phase 1
Data Collection and Analysis: Phase 2
