Building a network infrastructure means planning for network
support. Without the staff and technology in place to
repair and upgrade the network, it will not work as you
planned. One of the critical issues that the support
organization will face is the network's Acceptable Use Policy
for your schools and community. This section is designed to
build awareness around the many different factors which
contribute to the success of an effective support staff and an
Acceptable Use Policy.
Meeting Conducted by:
Steering Subcommittee Member Meeting Attended by:
Technology Planning Committee, Ongoing Support Subcommittee
Sample Agenda
(Estimated Time Required: 1 hour)
Review Agenda
Present Overview (Slide 1)
Present Objective Statement - Discuss Ongoing
Support Issues
Read Vision (Created in Session One)
View "Ongoing Support" Portion of Videotape
(Optional)
Introduce Support Requirements and Definitions
(Slides 2-7)
Brainstorm Suggestions on Security, Acceptable
Use Policy, and Response Times
___ Draft AUP (for purpose of discussion)
___ Review network management
issues
___ Review online documents on security
___ Prepare handouts
___ Invite local business representatives whose
companies use network technologies (they may
lend suggestions)
___ Invite local vendors who may be selected
___ Arrange for VCR and overhead projection
___ Assess sensitivity to issues of security
(impacts network design)
___ Brainstorm on Acceptable Use Policy (impacts
network design)
___ Agree on how Security and Acceptable Use
Policies will be approved
___ Agree on an acceptable turn-around time for
troubleshooting
___ List the reputable vendors in the area
___ List local businesses or other organizations
which can be visited to provide organizational and
budgetary guidelines
___ Determine if there is interest in a program
which uses students as support staff
Proposed Action Items
(Ongoing Support Subcommittee)
___ Identify skills in district (working with
Inventory Subcommittee)
___ Determine connectivity needs (working with
Inventory Subcommittee)
___ Determine technology required (working with
Connectivity Subcommittee)
___ Draft Security Policy
___ Draft Acceptable Use Policy
___ Agree on actions for breech of policy
___ Approve Security and Acceptable Use Policies
___ Propose network equipment design
___ Research equipment needs
___ Research standard protocols and interfaces
___ Evaluate vendors
___ Draft organizational chart
___ Propose at least two different support solutions
with rough dollar estimates, which include:
___ Technology
___ Personnel
___ Facilities refurbishing
Helpful Resources
Online Resources:
The Global SchoolNet
Foundation has a
comprehensive set of background material you may
need to keep your project moving forward.
The
Armadillo site has many good documents on K-12 Acceptable
Use Policies and background.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation
(EFF) hosts
information on policy and law as well as an extensive
collection of friendly Internet guides. You can also call them at 202-
544-9237.
This session will discuss the importance of ongoing support
and maintenance. These issues are often overlooked yet are
essential for your success. Networks require people and
technology to keep them functioning properly. As users place
new requirements on the network, it is critical that there be
a group in place that can upgrade the network to meet their
needs. Finally, it is this group of staff members that will be
responsible for ensuring that policies concerning acceptable
use and security are adhered to.
PLANNING FOR ONGOING SUPPORT
(Slide 2)
1. Technical and operational investment: Networks require
care and feeding by skilled personnel using network management
tools, which range in sophistication and ease of use. How you
implement these tools will depend largely upon the money you
have to spend.
2. Leveraging resources: Further, some network management
tools can be shared. Many of these tools are capable of
monitoring the LANs and WANs to which they are directly and
indirectly connected. If your network is based on open and
standard technologies, you can share network management tools
across the entire network. By using these tools to predict and
warn of potential problems, the staff will be able to help
avoid many time-consuming crises. You can then reduce the
number of people that are in the field to troubleshoot and
repair problem areas.
3. Security and Acceptable Use Policies: Adequate monitoring
technologies also help ensure that Security and Acceptable Use
Policies are adhered to. If a breech occurs, these tools can be
very helpful in discovering the source of the infraction,
allowing support personnel to quickly re-configure the network
to deter future problems.
ORGANIZATIONAL REQUIREMENTS
(Slide 3)
1. On-site support staff: Probably the most critical aspect of
an effective support organization is to have a person or group
of people on site to answer questions from end users and to
solve simple technical problems. Even though many technical
problems can be solved quickly and easily with some routine
troubleshooting, it is critical to have a person on site who
is familiar with rudimentary problems. In the event that the
on-site staff cannot fix the trouble, they will know how to
contact someone who has the required skills to solve the
problem. Finally, it is often the on-site personnel who will
be responsible for seeing that the Acceptable Use Policy is
adhered to. As appropriate, this group will monitor the
network for infractions of the policy and ensure that
corrective actions are taken.
2. Level-two support staff: The level-two support staff will
provide what is often referred to as a help desk function.
When on-site support staff are unable to resolve an issue,
they will report it to the second-level staff. This group will
most likely attempt to troubleshoot the problem by providing
instruction over the telephone. In some networks they may be
able to log in to the remote network and explore the
environment. Once they are confident that they have exhausted
their options remotely, they will establish a time to meet at
the school site and work the issue.
At some point, if the staff is unable to solve the
problem, they will most likely call the equipment or service
vendor's support staff. This activity may or may not cost the
school additional funds, depending on the support contract
negotiated between the school and the vendor. The time frame
in which the vendor is committed to solving the issue is
negotiated under contract between the two organizations.
The level-two staff will also be responsible for
troubleshooting network break-ins. In the event of an
infraction, the level-two support staff will attempt to
discover its source and prevent the event from being repeated.
If the problem persists, this group will be responsible for
re-configuring the network or working with network service and
equipment vendors to solve the problem.
3. Specialty teams: Finally, the support staff at each site
and operating at every school level, should be organized into
specialty teams. These teams should be responsible for
managing the aspects of the network that require coordinated
or special attention. In many cases, all of these functions
might be performed by the same support staff.
As the plan and network usage evolves, the Internet
connection may need to be upgraded. A team should be in place
to monitor the effectiveness of the connection and to make the
necessary modifications. Further, as new connectivity vendors
become established in your area, their services and fees will
need to be evaluated.
A similar function will be undertaken by a team which
will evaluate the evolving uses of the network and determine
the equipment, vendors, and standards that will be required to
meet these growing needs. This group will be responsible for
setting the strategic direction of the networks and the manner
in which upgrades will be handled.
There should also be a team assigned to evaluate and
plan for building construction and modifications which meet
the demands of the networks. Besides legally-mandated building
codes, there are many factors to consider as to where network
equipment should be located and how wiring should be
installed.
Finally, all of the policies, standards, and procedures
agreed to by the specialty teams should be well documented. A
well-documented implementation ensures that all persons
involved in the support, maintenance, and even use of the
network always have a source of information on how the network
operates and why. Without this documentation, if key personnel
leave the organization, your schools may suffer untimely
setbacks as they bring themselves back up to speed in
effective management of the network.
WHAT IS REQUIRED OF STAFF
(Slide 4)
Personnel responsible for troubleshooting and resolving
end-user issues are a critical part of the networking
infrastructure. They will have to handle many stressful
situations that require time and patience to resolve.
1. Communication skills: Probably the most important thing
needed to make users feel that their problems are being
addressed. Staff must speak in a language that users can
understand. In the absence of good communications between
network users and staff, tension and dissatisfaction tend to
arise.
2. Technical skills: The staff should be able to understand
and manage the operation of network equipment and protocols.
For every piece of network equipment and each application, a
staff member needs to know how it works and how it impacts
other hardware, applications, and protocols on the network. As
network problems arise, a technical expert will often need to
be familiar with several aspects of the network in order to
isolate the problem at hand. Without a firm grasp of the
technical workings of the network, the ability to find the
root of a given problem may prove extremely difficult and time
consuming. Even when a technologist's skills are well honed,
finding and solving network issues is often a complex task.
Therefore, technical staff may also need tremendous
persistence and patience in addition to technical know-how.
3. Experience: Probably the best way to assess the
capabilities of support personnel is to evaluate their
experience. What have they worked with in the past, and in
what context - another school site, a business, a university?
There are many different types of networks in the world, and
an aptitude and interest in working with one type of equipment
does not necessarily imply an aptitude and interest in working
with all types.
4. Flexibility: Finally, support staff must be interested in
learning about supporting new technologies. If they are not
willing to continually expand their horizons, their users will
be left behind the curve of the new developments that
inevitably develop to enhance the enjoyment and usefulness of
the network.
IDENTIFICATION OF RESOURCES
(Slide 5)
1. Resources from within: Where will these resources come
from? While these are highly marketable skills which draw high
salaries in most institutions, they need not cost the school
an extraordinary amount of money. It may be possible to find
many of the skills you need within the current staff. With
some training and retraining of the persons already involved
in keeping your technology operational, you may go a long way
toward finding the resources you need. Additionally, across
the country there are many programs that use students to
support and maintain the network infrastructure. This approach
has proven to be highly successful and provides the students
with valuable skills once they graduate, regardless of the
occupation or career they choose.
2. Resources from outside: No doubt you will also need to look
for resources outside of the school. These may come in the
form of paid consultants or partnerships with local businesses
or universities. Consultants in this field can be expensive,
so you should carefully plan how you will use their skills to
their fullest potential. Some consultants may be in a position
to donate their expertise to your project, especially if their
commitment is limited, so it is a good idea to explore this
option as you begin negotiations. It is also important to
enlist the assistance of local businesses and universities.
Many times these organizations are willing to work in an
advisory or planning capacity.
ROLE OF MANAGEMENT AND SUPPORT GROUP
(Slide 6)
1. Technologies to be supported: The selection of standard
network technologies is a major factor in reducing the level
of technical sophistication needed in management tools and
personnel. As much as possible, you should attempt to minimize
the number of different types of equipment and service vendors
that the staff must support. This will make their job much
easier and will allow them to operate more effectively.
Additionally, the more equipment you purchase from a single
vendor, the more clout you have within the vendor
organization. This is especially important as you look to your
vendors for product support and assistance in planning for
upgrades.
2. Financial considerations: There are financial advantages to
adhering to standards and enlisting vendors as partners. There
are economies-of-scale as vendors are more likely to discount
the price of their equipment to please larger clients. For
instance, a vendor is more likely to discount the price on ten
units of a product than on one or two. Vendors are more likely
to negotiate price if they believe it will result in repeat
purchases as your network expands.
In addition, by using standard technology, the cost of
upgrading your equipment will be minimized. Your investment in
used equipment may not be lost, as a software installation or
simple replacement of a card may be all that is necessary to
increase performance of the equipment. Older yet reliable
equipment may be re-installed as an upgrade to a smaller site
or to an area with less demanding requirements.
3. Security and Appropriate Use: Security is a concern on
every network. The network needs to be designed to prevent
users either inside or outside the school from obtaining
unauthorized access to restricted data. There are trade-offs
between ensuring that a network is totally secure and limiting
the freedom that users have in taking advantage of all of its
resources. Networks which handle sensitive materials may be
made entirely inaccessible to other users. Users on these
secure networks may be able to send email to others but it may
be impossible for them to share resources or to access other
materials. There are less limiting ways to secure a network,
but they may be expensive or lower the network's performance.
While it is important to ensure that outsiders don't
gain unauthorized access to your network, it may also be
important to keep your users from gaining unauthorized access
to other networks. Some schools have Acceptable Use Policies
that restrict the type of material their students may access.
Others leave it to the discretion of the classroom teacher,
while still others allow unrestricted access to the net.
Nearly all schools require that parents sign a consent form
that details the risk of students discovering controversial
material while exploring the Internet. This relieves the
school of the responsibility to closely supervise every
student (a difficult if not impossible task), and allows
parents to make decisions about what they deem to be
appropriate for their children.
Depending on how you connect to the Internet, you may
also face other restrictions. Government-sponsored connections
often bar commercial traffic from their facilities. These
policies are constantly changing (usually in the direction of
fewer restrictions) so it pays to keep up to date with them.
ROLE OF MANAGEMENT AND SUPPORT GROUP (continued)
(Slide 7)
4. Attempt to predict the future: The support staff will be
responsible for leading efforts to plan for growth. They will
have to work closely with other staff members to assess
growing network requirements and to plan for the resources you
will need. As the staff becomes more experienced at managing
the networks currently in place, they will also become adept
at identifying and evaluating technologies and vendors that
meet your needs well into the future.
5. Always a need to upgrade: It is difficult to plan very far
ahead. However, as newer applications create a growing demand
for the graphical display of information and more interactive
sessions you will almost certainly require new technology and
faster connections.