QUESTION: [Editor's Note: This question is based on Jim Taylor's Field Journal from 2/27/97] The above is all very (extremely) interesting (Like all the things your team writes and organize), however no mention is made if this is a symmetrical problem i.e. if there was data loss 6 minutes before and also after the occultation. That means the ^total^ data loss was 12 minutes. This information is very critical for any explanation. (You emphasize earlier, implying assymmetrical) Can you give me the calculation what the minumum time should have been i.e. COS (declination) * diameter of jupiter / speed of Galileo. diameter of jupiter = 143800 km The factor COS (declination) represents the hight above the equator (ecliptic?) of Jupiter. (Maximum dec = 0, Minumum dec = 90) This information is also important. When Galileo is lower above the equator as predicted, ^total^ time of occultation will be longer as "expected". ANSWER from Jim FH Taylor on April 8, 1997: I will start out by saying that we eventually found the cause of the 6-minute-early ingress. It was an error in the ingress time in a file used to generate the human-readable "space flight operations schedule" (SFOS) that virtually everyone on the flight team uses. The SFOS showed ingress 6 minutes later than it actually occurred. The egress time was in error by the same amount. The SFOS showed egress 6 minutes later than it actually occurred. Once I had determined these facts and made sure that the times of the next occultation will be more thoroughly checked, I had to go on to other things. Why didn't I mention these errors in the Journal page you read? After all, the answer was known before the Journal was "published" in "Online". Well, I didn't know it by end of day on February 27, when I wrote the Journal. I wanted the Journal to reflect our *best state of knowledge* at the time it was written. At that time, I only knew about the early ingress. We were not expecting to receive telemetry data immediately at egress. So I had no informatioin about egresss comparable to the lost telemetry frame at ingress. The radio science man, Randy Herrera, told me in our telephone conversation that he thought the egress had occurred early also; he also said that he has seen early ingress at other occultations, though not by such an extreme amount. I included paraphrases of his speculations at the end of Journal. We both knew there could simply be an error which, in fact, was the cause. Randy Herrera gave me an equatorial radius of 71492 km, including the oblateness, and defined at the 1 "bar" atmospheric pressure level. >This information is also important. When Galileo is lower >above the equator as predicted, ^total^ time of occultation >will be longer as "expected". I understand what you're trying to get at. However, I want to get home tonight, so I'll merely provide you one assumption and some trajectory data, and let you make the calculation. Randy Herrera told me that this occultation was nearly equatorial. Just assume that everything (Jupiter, earth, and the spacecraft orbit around Jupiter) are in a plane. The trajectory data I see is included in a weekly status report. For the period February 6 - March 13, I extracted the values, as follows. The Jupiter radio occultation occurred from 20:17 UTC on February 26 to 09:53 UTC February 27. These are ground receive times for the downlink, and they include the 6-minute correction! February 6, 1997 Distance from Earth 912,537,600 km (6.1 AU) Distance from Sun 770,169,800 km (5.2 AU) Speed WRT Jupiter 8,700 km per hour Distance from Jupiter 5,111,100 km (71.5 RJ) February 13, 1997 Distance from Earth 905,741,700 km (6.1 AU) Distance from Sun 767,982,500 km (5.1 AU) Speed WRT Jupiter 15,700 km per hour Distance from Jupiter 4,031,500 km (56.4 RJ) February 20, 1997 Distance from Earth 896,554,700 km (6.0 AU) Distance from Sun 765,175,000 km (5.1 AU) Speed WRT Jupiter 64,900 km per hour Distance from Jupiter 689,500 km (9.6 RJ) February 27, 1997 Distance from Earth 893,471,100 km (6.0 AU) Distance from Sun 769,610,000 km (5.1 AU) Speed WRT Jupiter 18,000 km per hour Distance from Jupiter 4,157,300 km (58.2 RJ) March 6, 1997 Distance from Earth 885,616,700 km (5.9 AU) Distance from Sun 770,466,400 km (5.2 AU) Speed WRT Jupiter 9,800 km per hour Distance from Jupiter 5,833,100 km (81.6 RJ) March 13, 1997 Distance from Earth 875,194,600 km (5.9 AU) Distance from Sun 770,038,300 km (5.2 AU) Speed WRT Jupiter 6,900 km per hour Distance from Jupiter 6,375,900 km (89.2 RJ)