QUESTION: If Jupiter's composition is different than that of the planets closer to the sun, why do Jupiter's moons have iron, and why is Jupiter like a solar system within the solar system? ANSWER from Robert West on Jan. 17, 1996: The planet Jupiter grew so large when it formed four and a half billion years ago that its strong gravity was able to hold the light gases like hydrogen and helium which were abundant in the early solar system but were pushed away by the sun's energy after the planets formed. The smaller, inner planets (Mercury to Mars) were not able to hold on to the light gases, and were left with mostly rocky material and iron. Because Jupiter and its moons retained all the elements, they also retained iron and other rocky and icy materials. The moons of Jupiter lost any early atmosphere they may have had because they were not big enough to hold on to it, so they, like the inner planets, are mostly rocky and icy. As the moons of Jupiter formed, the closest of the large moons (Io) was warmed by the heat of the early Jupiter much more so than were the more distant moons. Because Io formed in a warmer region near Jupiter, not as much ice was able to condense on its surface, and it is made mostly of rocky material, whereas more and more ice was able to form and be part of the moons (Europa, Ganymede, and Callisto) more distant from Jupiter. The different compositions of these moons reflect the conditions of their formation, much like the compositions of the planets refect the conditions of their formation, with Mercury being closest to the Sun, and having almost no ice, whereas Earth has liquid water and ice because it is farther from the sun where the temperature is cooler. So we can say that Jupiter and its large moons are similar to the sun and planets, like a little solar system within the solar system.